DMusic.com | for indie musicians and fans | Free MP3 music downloads - Forums: The General Forum: Do You Prefer Good or Bad Comments on Your Music

Forums > The General Forum

Do You Prefer Good or Bad Comments on Your Music

gumbee	Date: October 11, 2004 @ 2:04 AM I am a newbie at dmusic, but I have been listening and commenting for many years on musik that unknown artist are producing. I am very blunt and honest in my comments, which has, at times, has had artist "throwing darts my way". I see no reason why artist(s) should become upset after a derogatory, negative comment was made on a trak. Artist(s) know, "UP FRONT" when they upload their musik, that listeners like myself will comment either way. Artist(s) who can not take negative comments, in my humble opinion, should take their musik and upload it to a site that does not have the options of anyone commenting. Remember, comments are like A$.H...., we all got one.
povertystricken	Date: October 11, 2004 @ 4:14 PM I wish they all had one
acousticgrrl	Date: October 12, 2004 @ 5:17 AM ^^ I agree with Gumbee except where he says "derrogatory, negative comments." You can post negative comments without being an asshole about it. Either way, people should use tact and be honest.
gumbee	Date: October 12, 2004 @ 10:38 AM I agree with you acousticgrrl, you are correct. My opinion is that Derogatiory Comments are not/should not normally be the standard for any commentor(what I call PeePeRs). But for me, It depends on the artist/genre I am listening to. For xample... I like Gary Tuckers Styl, Vocal, Content&Delivery, Timing, and Production. If I listened to one trak I did not like, I would comment in a way that Gary Tucker would take positvely, but be blunt but articulate. I would not leave derogatory comments on a trak to him, and for good reason, that being, that his music isnt filled with abusive, fowl, deameaning, phycopathic lyrics like some of the artist in the Rap Genre. Xample... Hoodcroft, who raps about hating school and all that it represnts, and they dont stop there, that isnt good enough. They then rap about very teachers that are there to help them with their future goals in life, and wanting to kill them/him. (I could be off a hair, but I am not going back to review it to get it right) And as they rap this trak, they are throwing out words i wouldnt descibe in a public forum. If I left a negative comment on a Hoodcroft trak, as I would on Gary Tuckers Trak, they would laugh. My opinion is that the proper way to respond to some artist in the rap genre that are like Hoodcroft is to "fight fire with fire" and be as demeaning and derogatory as to them as they are to other people, or to the general listening audience, so they understand in their termonology.
acousticgrrl	Date: October 12, 2004 @ 4:43 PM You don't have to call them a dumbass or a shithead to get it across. Name calling is not helpful. If you think the music sucks, there's nothing wrong with saying that as long as you explain why. I try to be constructive in all comments I leave. Even if it's "Hmmm, learn how to play guitar first." The kids you're describing are doing it for shock value and isn't meant to appeal to someone like you anyway. If anything, the fact that you find it offensive encourages them. That's just what I think...
gumbee	Date: October 12, 2004 @ 5:44 PM Again, I agree acousticgrrl in that name calling is out of the question I personally do not personalize my comments towards a artist. I keep my comments on the Trak/Song, not the person(s). Intellectual Constructive Criticism is fine for the majority of the artist, but unfortunantly, for some, its isnt possible. As far as the "offensive comments encourages them" that is more true than not but that is their decission to make. But there is hope, and this is a true xample, and has happened on several (3) occasions thruout the years.. 2 weeks ago, I had a artist who I had gave a "comment-al Blessing to" 2 years ago, emailed me and wanted me to peep his new trak, and it was 100 percent better. He told me that the props(or good comments) on his old trak starting falling off, and no one was peeping his trak, but it wasnt my comment that turned ppl around he said, it was his inability to produce a quality trak that people liked, and now he's continueing getting props for 6 months str8t, and he wanted to thank me for being so brutally honest with him. It changed his thinking, and hes happier now. acousticgrrl, I wish that would happen more often than not.
gumbee	Date: October 12, 2004 @ 5:57 PM acousticgrrl By the way, I love rap and dont mind the lyrikz, it comez wit da teror-tory, and have given many props for many rapppaz. Thanks for the feedback. End of my feedbackz. have a good 1.
LilVIetBalla	Date: October 16, 2004 @ 2:00 PM yea... i think u should tell honest commments, not some bullshit. cuz the bull might steer you the wrong way and keep u doin from wat u reli be doin.
dicktruth	Date: October 17, 2004 @ 7:54 AM As long as the comment is honest, I'll take what I can get.
GTLive	Date: October 17, 2004 @ 9:17 AM On a side note, the principal from my son Brian's school had me in to discuss his many behavioral problems, and we have determined that he misbehaves in order to get "Negative Attention". For some reason that flashed me right to this very thread, so here I am!
zique	Date: October 17, 2004 @ 9:58 AM negative comments are to be expected...they keep me grounded and help me strive for improvement.at the very least they make me question and re-evaluate my work ,I try to see were they are coming from or points of view.The only time i have a problem with negative comments is when they are personal attacks on me,(name calling ,derrogatory statements and such).and i usually dont even have a problem with that,its expected. but to have the same kind of comment again(on a different song) from the same person,hits a nerve... if my music affects someone bad enough to attack me personally,then why would they even want come back to hear to more of my tunes and waiste time on making another derragatory statement about someone you dont even know.
Intergalacti...	Date: October 17, 2004 @ 4:21 PM Neither, i like respectful comments.
hueseph	Date: October 17, 2004 @ 6:15 PM Honesty is a form of respect. It shows that the person commenting wants you to improve rather than continue in what may be less than appealing efforts or efforts that could be moreso appealing than they already are or that your work truly is exemplary and they want to encourage you to continue producing that level of work. Sycophants are benificial to no-one but themselves and thoughtless flatterers don't think you can handle the truth. Is this respect?
HCizgood	Date: October 18, 2004 @ 4:50 AM yo yo this yo boy mada from the infamous HC crew, ima tell yall something right cheya and espsilly this dude gumbee, I say you aint feelin it keep yo got damn opinion to yo self, fa real kid you dont know me who i be, where i grow up the skool system is currpt boy and thas why i dont like school, and if educatoin aint takin me to another level then im gonna find another way to elevate my self, weather it be through rappin or sellin crack ima be my own man. SO you konw what you lil emo bastard, I do spit on my teachers, cuz the shcool system spit on me. The school system aint teach me shit, my people need freedom we tryin to get all we can get, and all those highschool teachers can suck my dick tellin my white man lies straight bullshit. and people ask me Mada Mada how you gonna change it up for tha year 2010 and i tell em look ima do it how i been doin it gulley as fuck. Dog im so gutter im hangin off the fuckin shingles of my apartment. SO ima say rightnow for this whole topic, FUCK A HATER
jess1561	Date: October 18, 2004 @ 6:35 AM I prefer constructive critism...
Izekial	Date: October 18, 2004 @ 7:06 AM God dammit, HCizgood. It’s ignorant people like you who give ignorant people like me a bad name: I’m what’s called a civil, compromising peon. You’re what’s called an obnoxious moron. We’re the same species, but we’re different breeds. Or check this out, dog... if you can’t take five seconds out of your wasted life to get an education and some manners, you will automatically be viewed as an egotistical neanderthal, a malefactor among the common villain, and there’s no way in hell I’d take you seriously. Gumbee here was just making a point... a disjointed point, but a point none the less. He wasn’t firing on anyone. Why do people like you insist on “taking offence” or “resisting” or... I don’t even know what you’re doing! So you’re a victim... cry me a fucking river. It’s not like you’re the only person on this fucking planet who has problems. God. Do you have any idea how many of your clones walk into my work on a weekly basis? Listen... I overreact sometimes too, like if someone steps on my toes or something, but I don’t stoke the fire. Be bigger than that. Why do you even care if Gumbee talks shit about your music or if he just wants to leave some constructive criticism somewhere? Are you drunk? I wish I was drunk right now. Then maybe I could ignore the occasional asshole that passes through here just to stick his dumb dick in the mashed potatoes.
Izekial	Date: October 18, 2004 @ 7:17 AM And guys, keep your fighting to yourselves. Shit ya'll... and Gumbee, if you think the only way to get across to some people is through blunt naivety, you’re a horrible retard and I love you. Next time just leave your “constructive criticism” and if they’re immature about it, you tried, and it’s officially ok to say, “Well, fuck you buddy. I’m out.” Then you kids stop fighting, or I’ll make you hug in the corner for ten minutes.
StuBu	Date: October 18, 2004 @ 9:20 AM I would hate to hear bad comments, but that just wouldn't help me much would it? I guess I'd like to see a positive comment and then a subtle hint of, well this and this could be .... I teach ESL and there's nothing worse for a teacher to correct a student in a negative way. So what's a good way? I'm still trying to figure that out.
Absalute	Date: October 18, 2004 @ 1:01 PM AY FOOL! Who the fuck you think you is? You punk pussy ass marshmellow soft ass muhfugga. Fuck a school system. Yeah i said it muhfugga. Yeah I spit on my teachers face and yeah I said i kill that bitch. Say I wont. How you gonna be throwing HC name round on random as shit talking bout they saying shit I wouldnt even say on a board you sweet ass pop tart muhfugga. Let HC come out your mouth again. Gumbee ass bitch you dont know the first thing bout me so how you gonna say it aint right to be talking shit bout these fake ass teachers. They aint showing me respect, the fuck you think imma be doing to them. And Izekial you need to hop the fuck of that high horse. talking bout my boy Mada being ignorant shit. Fool you dont know Mada. You dont know shit. Mada will break your shit. Keep yappin bitches.
hueseph	Date: October 18, 2004 @ 8:53 PM And they say the school system is failing. Here are some fine examples of "creative grammar and spelling". Who says comics aren't teaching the kids something? How many of you can properly spell blammo?
gumbee	Date: October 18, 2004 @ 9:27 PM HCizgood, Your correct in one thing, and that is that I should have not used your Bands name in a Public Forum or Gary Tuckers as examples. Please accept my apolgies 2 both of you. That is why/what Comments are for on an Artist(s) Page. You can review my comment about your Trak on your page. My comment on your page still stands, and hasn't changed about the Trak. End of my public comment.
Amp	Date: October 19, 2004 @ 12:49 PM a-yo str8 up i know where hc is coming from, but bro to express it in that way thats just like totally wrong....so when people comment on ur music u gonna flip when you here like 1 little bad comment?? if someone leaves a comment there its because they had a reason to. no one on the site (i think) just goes around leaving bad comments on everyones music. and complaining about your life..like Izekial said everyone in the world has problems...you gotta try and work around them dun make em worst by acting up...a-yo you know wha i do when i feel like the worlds on my shoulders....i write...u should try that..u get alot better lyrics when you work like that..but anywayz that how i feel about this whole situation... ~1~
hueseph	Date: October 19, 2004 @ 8:34 PM Why do I get the feeling that HCizgood and Absalute are the same person just trying to pose as people standing up for himself? Hmmmmm....................
TameasDust	Date: October 20, 2004 @ 2:14 AM Does that mean he can go fuck himself ??? ... soooooooooo y'all prefer any comment as long as it is well written and insightful as to the listeners point of view on your music
Izekial	Date: October 20, 2004 @ 2:50 AM No no, HORNY comments. How many times do I have to say it.
TameasDust	Date: October 20, 2004 @ 2:53 AM six
gumbee	Date: October 20, 2004 @ 12:53 PM I should not have used any Artist(s) as example in your forum. Please accept my apology. As a PeePer of musik, I believe that what you wrote is what I strive to do, being well written and insightful, whether it be positive or negative. Thank You
TameasDust	Date: October 23, 2004 @ 11:31 AM what the heck ... have fun
hciztehsux	Date: January 11, 2005 @ 2:45 PM To all people who took "hcizgood" seriously: I am laughing my fucking ass off right now. Does everyone want to know a "secret" about the esteemed ghetto ganstas of Hoodcroft? The band name "Hoodcroft" is their, ahem, clever way of changing the name of their subdivision in southwest Durham, Woodcroft. They are a bunch of white middleclass punks who live in one of the best neighbourhoods in Durham. A complete sham. The best part (IMO) is that Woodcroft is districted to a historically black highschool (Hillside), but everyone in the area transferres to the richer, more white high school (Jordan High, of "JHS Diss"). What a bunch of idiots. Feel free to call them names. I'll start it off with the two most apt ones: HC is a group of no-talent posers. My husband and I have since moved away but I remember their petty, strutting selves shambling around drunk or speeding through the neighbourhood streets. -S. Brown
imemine	Date: January 11, 2005 @ 6:03 PM It's back! Thought this one had died a while ago! I just prefer comments!
shadowself	Date: January 11, 2005 @ 7:17 PM I prefer good comments of course, but the bad comments are fine as long as they are constructive as opposed to just "j00 sux0rz".
JudgeMental	Date: January 12, 2005 @ 5:43 AM I spent many years doing live shows...so I prefer people to just shut up and listen! Seriously though, Ive never uploaded to an interactive site - I just dont find the comments very helpful or relevant. A lot of people just want to see their name in lights, so their comments are usually based on personal likes & dislikes and are rarely objective enough to make much difference. Nothing wrong with interaction...but dont expect it to teach you anything other than all about the person who posted.
imemine	Date: January 12, 2005 @ 9:42 AM Well---the name fits!
hciztehsux	Date: January 12, 2005 @ 10:31 PM Yeah, yeah, I know it's an immature screen name. I save my usual sn for things that are actually important, just thought it was funny how you guys started apologizing after the two group members posted about their oh-so hard lives and how tough they are. It's at least fair for everyone to know they're full of it, right? I'm dropping the subject unless anyone cares to prolong it
Jesuszilla	Date: January 13, 2005 @ 2:33 PM J'habite dans une boite
jeddak	Date: January 14, 2005 @ 10:22 PM Honest criticism is the best. I don't want to receive only positive comments - I want to know both what people dislike and what people like about my music. Sincere feedback is what will help me understand how to improve my craft.
Omnipotent12	Date: January 15, 2005 @ 1:17 AM The way I see it....negative comments means they can say bad things about your songs, which that cannot help you at all. Receiving positive comments is a great way to receive. In addition, positive comments will come with tips/lessons as well. If the person made a sincere comment, gave you tips, and encouraged you.....that's a positive comment. I don't believe in negative comments....only haters make negative comments
Spott	Date: January 15, 2005 @ 10:07 AM No preference for me between good or bad, as long as it's constructive.
AdamsGod	Date: January 17, 2005 @ 4:22 PM any comment, aslong as it isnt bullshit!
Absalute	Date: February 21, 2005 @ 8:31 PM oh ima prolong this bitch, you betta be glad you got out the hood while you did. Cuz like they say you can take the person out of the croft, but you cant take my dick out of your mouth, you skank bitch. You best be glad you left while you dids. Ima find out who you is S.Brown i iant stupd' i can find out. And we were never drunk, we just were having a good time, and old bitchess like you fuckin us up and callin the po po and thats why we showed disrespect fo teachas police and skanky bitches like youse!!!Blucca
TameasDust	Date: February 22, 2005 @ 3:12 AM and your point is???
hueseph	Date: February 23, 2005 @ 2:00 AM Here's a concept: A comment is only as bad as how YOU take it. You can say one sentance to three different people an they will all take it a different way. If you choose to hear it in a bad way, it will affect you in a negative way. If you choose to accept it however as an opinion and a valid criticizm, you will push forward to improve yourself and there's NOTHING negative about that.
zedsalt	Date: February 23, 2005 @ 11:02 AM If someone wrote an especially clever, funny review that just SLAMMED me, I'd save it for my presspack. I'd think that folks who have to wade through a lot of 'packs would find that refreshing and memorable. A writer once compared my stuff to Syd Barret's solo work and Alexander Spence's "Oar". You could tell by the tone and context that he intended it as a scathing insult, but the fact is that I LOVE those albums! If he would've thrown in something along the lines of the Hampton Grease Band or Captain Beefheart, my ego would've swelled to unmanageable proportions. Seriously, if you're going to make a negative comment, it should involve suggestions for improvement and some sort of recognition of the fact that it is just an opinion. Not only are you more likely to do some real good that way, you lower your chances of sounding like an ass. Then again, if your compulsion to insult someone is VERY strong, it may be time to admit that you ARE an ass. You know what they say in those twelve step programs: admitting that you have a problem is the first step to curing it.
Rodrica	Date: February 23, 2005 @ 11:35 AM I prefer to visit someone's music page as an appreciative audience rather than a self-appointed expert. If I enjoy or I'm impressed by someone's music, irrespective of whether it is the way I would have done it and irrespective of whether it is my usual taste in music...then I like to show my appreciation for their efforts and hard work. However if I don't like the music (for whatever reason) then I prefer to keep a diplomatic silence. I, as another musician, do not have the right to state how anyone should or should not present their music...that is a matter of personal taste. I never attempt to sound knowledgeable and I never take the "expert's line". If an individual actually INVITES me to privately criticise their work or elaborate on my opinions, then that's another matter...but it doesn't alter the fact that even private comments are still only personal opinions. (you only have to listen to record industry bosses arguing over what's good/bad). Very few of us here are complete novices and undoubtedly most of us are sufficiently qualified, trained, or musically experienced to make our own decisions on how our own music should sound. I agree with an earlier comment made. Comments on songs tell you more about the person who posted the comment than about your own music. Afterall, it's their opinion and their interpretation...no one can get inside the head of the musician who created the song. Also, most musicians are highly self-critical when it comes to their music...I think it would be egotistical on the part of the reviewer if they assume an artist is incapable of hearing their own mistakes. Perfection in music is an impossible goal...but one we all strive for. Musicians will always try to improve their art in their own way...and opinions are just representations of those who voice them.
JudgeMental	Date: February 24, 2005 @ 4:36 AM I earned a living for 40 years as a session/live musician so I speak from experience. Ive never uploaded to websites, but had many press reviews. Its never failed to amaze me how those who comment try and justify their rude or patronizing remarks as "helpful" or "honest". musicians have a hard enough time as it is...if you truly wanted to "help" you would show support and be positive publicly and keep the negative stuff to a quiet private discussion with the artist alone, rather than using a public platform to sound off. Remember, just because you have an opinion it dont make you an expert, neither does it mean you are right or accurate. If you think your opinion is the only correct one, then that is nothing more than egotism and narrow-mindedness. If you truly want an artist to hear you out, then do it privately so that they know you are not merely a self-publicist or just being malicious...because nobody is impressed by a loudmouth.
BOWILLIE	Date: February 24, 2005 @ 9:32 PM damn!...ya'll got me scared to check my comments......
hueseph	Date: February 25, 2005 @ 12:53 AM An honest opinion can be taken the wrong way. A comment is only as bad as we percieve it to be. If someone has gone out of their way to "be an ass" it will be obvious to everyone who sees the post. I don't know about you but I can form my own opinion when I listen to someones music. You can choose to ignore a malicious comment and let it end there or you can draw it out by persuing the basher. I personally haven't had anyone bash me but I know that it can happen and that'a fine. Some ego's bruise all too easily. As a session musician JudgeMental I'm sure you're quite aware of that. Sometimes there is nothing you can say to mend a bruised ego. I think this site gives a good reason to toughen up the skin: http://www.digitalharmony.com.au/ Music is a fickle industry. Only the one's who can work past the rejection will make it anywhere. At that only a handfull of those will continue to an exceptionally lucrative career.
hueseph	Date: February 25, 2005 @ 1:00 AM Oh click on recording contracts at that site.
JudgeMental	Date: February 25, 2005 @ 5:23 AM I dont want to get into protracted discussions about this but i'll answer the last post. As a pro, egos dont come into it. I am paid to do a job and I do it - i have to respect the person i'm working for. Respect is something a few people could do with learning on this site. My last, somewhat lost, point was that musicians are usually more than capable of taking rejection and criticism and they always have a hard time. But most of us will only accept it from record companies, publishers, venue owners, PAYING audiences and invited friends/those whose style we admire or compliments our own. My reasoning - This site offers no financial reward, no contracts and does not pay for the music. Neither do any of its visitors! This is not an appropriate place to concentrate on personal issues or to "toughen" anyone up. Leave that to the professional organizations - they have something to offer the artist and have a right to make demands in return. Therefore not everyone wants a critique here - many simply want to share their music with their friends. This site is supposed to be here to help and support fellow musicians... Let's not try acting like a poor man's Simon Cowell. Because my point is that the Simon Cowell's of this world (aside from the publicity stunts) are in a position to offer the right artist a check at the end of the day and will put a lot of financial backing behind their artists. So they have a right to be demanding if approached. But I don't see any critics on this site writing any checks. We get FREE music on this site...let's not look a gifthorse in the mouth huh? Sorry if this isnt concise but i've been recording all night and I'm f*ckd.
hueseph	Date: February 25, 2005 @ 7:11 PM Point taken. All I'm saying is you can't blame someone else for how you feel. Words are only words abd at times can be taken the wrong way.
zedsalt	Date: February 26, 2005 @ 11:08 AM I have to respectfully disagree with Rodrica on one point. The ultrapersonal nature of the creative process is precisely the reason I value outside opinions and suggestions for improvement. It really helps me to hear from someone who wasn’t involved in a piece’s creation and doesn’t have any kind of emotional investment in it. Hmm…I guess it’s not so much a “disagreement” as a difference in personal preferences, but you get my drift. Ironically, Rodrica is the sort of person whose constructive criticism I’d put an inordinate amount of stock in. I say “inordinate” because I understand that the ability to make useful suggestions, musical talent, and eloquence are three separate and distinct traits…but I’d be the first to admit that I tend to lend more credence to the opinion of someone who’s a substantial talent (like her) and very well-spoken (again, she’s a good example). I mean, I consciously try to avoid those prejudices, but subconsciously…well…
zedsalt	Date: February 26, 2005 @ 11:11 AM Oh, and I really appreciate "RIYL"-style (recommended if you like____) comments. That’s one of those things that’s made more difficult for me by how close I am to my work.
smooka	Date: February 26, 2005 @ 2:00 PM It takes a combination of skills to be successful at conveying your message musically. It’s a complicated form of communication. You can never expect someone else to hear what you hear. The point of making music, I thought, is to fulfill your own need to feed your creative and expressive fire. I make music because it’s what I hear. not what I think your gonna hear. so good bad or indiffernt comments are just that.. comments.
Resiliance	Date: February 27, 2005 @ 6:04 AM Constructive criticism is what I strive for.
TameasDust	Date: March 23, 2005 @ 6:59 AM
biggles1	Date: March 24, 2005 @ 10:36 AM Any comment is a good comment as long as its constructive!!! or as far as I am concerned anyway!!
simulacrat	Date: March 24, 2005 @ 11:02 PM can you really choose which you get?
TameasDust	Date: March 25, 2005 @ 4:22 AM of course you can ... just get a bigger whip
simulacrat	Date: March 25, 2005 @ 10:39 AM oh... you're naughty
TameasDust	Date: August 7, 2005 @ 11:09 PM oooooooooooooo
just2ska	Date: August 9, 2005 @ 3:06 PM i'm pretty sure the obvious answer here is that you need both just as much. You need to know what you're doing good as well as bad... or else you'd get not nearly as far! Personally i like a combination...
mattbanx	Date: August 9, 2005 @ 3:28 PM Who's going to like everything someone does? While critiques can be good for pointing out things you can improve you might not see, critiques will always be subjective. The artists that have made it commercialy must have iron guts. Some like me, many won't. I don't lose any sleep over it. I take it, we are supposed to be here to learn and get better.
Snoogans775	Date: August 17, 2005 @ 8:45 PM I'm mean to people who are mean to me, it has nothing to do with the nature of their comment, since to them a bad song wohuldn't be a big deal. if they make it a big deal, they receive the wrath of my insecurity in overly scrutinous, honest comments on their music.
imemine	Date: August 18, 2005 @ 12:02 AM Man am I glad someone brought this up!
Snoogans775	Date: August 18, 2005 @ 12:14 AM if anybody's willing to read all of it, I'm sure there's a lot to be learned
AgentMGD	Date: August 18, 2005 @ 8:51 AM i tend to think artists/musicians would like an honest opinion about their music. i'm very blunt person when it comes to giving my opinions about something ...i don't try to avoid telling the negative while praising the positive. if your music/song sucks royally, expect a real critical review from me and i have actually done it twice here at dmusic - both musicians thanked me for my honesty. jmho
TameasDust	Date: October 8, 2005 @ 10:35 PM boo
TameasDust	Date: October 29, 2005 @ 11:22 PM
guitaroo	Date: November 2, 2005 @ 8:32 PM I agree with what AgentMGD said
HalloweenBat...	Date: November 2, 2005 @ 8:41 PM i prefer honest comments
hantu	Date: November 2, 2005 @ 8:56 PM honest comments... which i feel i rarely get unfortunately... but there are a few members that are honest and let me know what is crappy about my stuff... although sometimes im not too happy about the bad comments to be honest, but in the end i appreciate them more obviously coz they help me out more... so yeh honest comments all the way. although even i find it hard to be honest sometimes, but thats mainly because i don't want my jelously for someone elses work getting in the way... so yeh i find commenting relatively hard actually, which i also find stupid in a way.... i mean its just commenting.... its usually easier when you don't know the member at all... just listen and comment simple.... but yeh ... honest comments all the way
TameasDust	Date: December 4, 2005 @ 9:01 AM sooooooooo ... I take it that saying ... "this is a load of absolute crap ... how dare you assault my ears with this vulgar attempt at music ... talent is non existant in any of your family and least of all you ... The person who convinced you that you could record yourself and torture others should be fed slowly to a pack of fire ants ... I am surprised that the recording procution crew didn't barf all over and die on the spot when they heard this rampant ooozing vomit coming from someone that looked human ... Take my advice and donate yourself to the food chain of dinosaurs ... The less we hear from you again the happier humankind will be!" ... would not be a comment you would wish to hear
GeneHilbert	Date: December 4, 2005 @ 11:29 AM All-righty then........ I don't care - as long as it is your truthful and honest opinion. If I believe it has merit I might even attempt to correct things you don't like - if at all possible. If you like it.......? Thank You for listening. Either way, Thank You for your time and please visit again when you can.
hantu	Date: December 4, 2005 @ 1:50 PM "sooooooooo ... I take it that saying ... "this is a load of absolute crap ... how dare you assault my ears with this vulgar attempt at music ... talent is non existant in any of your family and least of all you ... The person who convinced you that you could record yourself and torture others should be fed slowly to a pack of fire ants ... I am surprised that the recording procution crew didn't barf all over and die on the spot when they heard this rampant ooozing vomit coming from someone that looked human ... Take my advice and donate yourself to the food chain of dinosaurs ... The less we hear from you again the happier humankind will be!" ... would not be a comment you would wish to hear" Well nobody would wish for that kind of comment silly ... but hell.... if that is the truth, then at least it will make you do something about what ur making rather then just keep making and uploading the same kind of stuff you mentioned above ..... no?
mental-torture	Date: December 4, 2005 @ 1:54 PM I prefer quality comments. Comments that say "hey, this song lacks bass" or "this song is total crap. there is not one good melody in it" stuff that will let me know what I can do to fix my next song.
TameasDust	Date: December 4, 2005 @ 1:55 PM sometimes people get that sort of comment from critics ... but critics are wannabe artists anyway
mental-torture	Date: December 4, 2005 @ 1:56 PM yes, but sometimes the critics are right, and as long as their right, its helpful
TameasDust	Date: December 6, 2005 @ 11:14 PM dots

Previous 100

Page: [ 1 2 ]

~~Next 100~~

Post A Reply
From:	Guest	(Icons - Linking)
Post: